Losing control of the manuscript

My thoughts about putting manuscripts on web sites has evolved over time.

Early in my career, it seemed like putting stuff out early was best; it gave some property rights. But I am inefficient, and reviewing/presenting changes your paper. The latest version is not like the early version, at least for my ambitious work. Sometimes the titles even change. You lose control of the manuscript and where it is circulated.

If the paper evolves, you can be screwed on the cite count—I have one paper with lots of cites, in total, even though the paper is cited in lots of different ways, and under different titles. Or even for incorrect points, since things were changed significantly over time.

And of course, referees routinely google a paper they are reviewing. There goes the blind review process. That problem is not large anyway—I would never submit a paper until it has been presented someplace first. Meaning that the reviewer likely knows who wrote the paper even if I did not put it out on the web first.

My current decision is not to put manuscripts on web sites until it has ‘settled down’ for a while. But that raises the possibility of losing the property rights to the idea.


3 responses to “Losing control of the manuscript

  1. Pingback: AECT Blog Track - Hanging Out My Shingle

  2. Maybe our disciplines are very different, because I don’t recall anyone losing “title” to an idea or argument. I don’t post papers because until I submit them to a journal, I tend to see them as too unpolished.

  3. Greg,
    In my discipline, there often are ‘races’ to be the first to publish a result—empirical and theoretical stuff.

    Sometmes the first paper goes to the ‘A’ journal and the second to a ‘B’ or even ‘C’ journal.

    I put stuff on as soon as I am confident that I want to lose control of where and how the manuscript circulates. Usually that is before I submit, but close enough so that there are no loose ends.

    Happy Labor Day!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s